I have cooked many a thing in my time. Some have turned out better than others. The only major cooking failure I can remember was when I was fourteen. My parents and brother had gone out for the evening, and I decided to stay in for some reason. I decided I was going to try and bake a cheesecake. For someone who had only made chocolate chip cookies up until that point, this was probably not the best choice, but I was an ambitious teenager. I looked up a recipe in the Joy of Cooking cookbook for New York Cheesecake. I walked to the local grocery store to get the ingredients we didn’t have at the house, and I embarked on my first real cooking adventure without my mom observing my every move.
An hour later, out came my cheesecake. It was the color of chocolate…yet there was no cocoa in this delicacy. The crust was…crunchy, to put it nicely. When my parents got home, they tried to choke down a piece of my culinary masterpiece, and tried to not completely destroy my cooking esteem. From that point on, I was a little more cautious in my endeavors, and since then, have become fairly confident in my culinary skills. I think the only cooking failures I had from that point on were the occasional burnt cookie.
Which brings me to this past weekend. Let me set the stage for you: Our church, Brentwood Church (Check it out, it’s amazing!) is about to go multi-site. We’ve maxed out the use of our current facility, and we are starting a 2nd campus so we can reach the Lynchburg community for Christ. (Jesus win!) Since we’re expanding and regrouping, the church has been having a series of vision nights, based on which serving team people are joining. Teecy, the director of host teams, asked me to bake some treats for her team’s vision night. I was so excited to help. I decided to bless the volunteers with a favorite recipe that my mom and I had made countless times throughout my growing-up years: Double Decker Brownies. I hear the name, and I start to get a sugar rush. They’re delicious…a layer of brownie, a layer of blondie, a thick, creamy chocolate frosting on top.
I baked the brownies Sunday night, and put the finishing touch, aka the chocolate frosting, on them when I got home from work Monday. As I was about to leave the house, I decided to sample them, just to make sure they turned out. Bad choice. As soon as I popped it in my mouth, I wanted to cry. The “brownies” were more of a dry cake. The flavor was fine—the consistency was WAY off. I had approximately 10 minutes to get them to the drop-off place, so making something else was WAY out of the question. I was completely ashamed of them, but I had no other option but to drop them off. As I crumpled, my roommate came to the rescue. She reminded me that no one would realize they were supposed to be the consistency of fudgy brownies. Cake would be fine to them! Although I was reassured for a moment, I couldn’t get over the fact that I had failed at something I loved—something that is a big part of my identity. Even more than this, I hated that the one time I have a major kitchen flub is the same night I have to serve my baking to hundreds of people. I guess that’s just God’s way of keeping me humble.
I haven’t decided if I’m throwing in the towel on this recipe, but if you want to give it a try, go for it! My memories of it are great…and I think part of it could be my outdated oven in my townhouse…or the fact that I made a double batch…who knows. They were a staple of my childhood, and are now a sign of my humility. Enjoy!
Double Decker Brownies
Brownie Mix
1 cup margarine
2 cups sugar
4 eggs
1 tsp. salt
2 tsp. vanilla
2 cups flour
½ cup chopped walnuts
2 squares unsweetened chocolate, melted
Chocolate frosting
¼ cup margarine, melted
1 oz. unsweetened chocolate (melted)
1 ½ tsp. vanilla
2 cups sifted confectioners sugar
2 ½ tbsp. milk.
Cream margarine and sugar. Add eggs, then rest of ingredients, except chocolate. Divide dough in half. Add 2 squares melted chocolate to ½ of the batter. Spread the chocolate batter in greased 9 x 13 pan. Cover this with the white batter. Bake for 30 minutes at 350 degrees. Remove from oven, allow to cool to room temperature.
In small bowl, combine margarine, chocolate and vanilla. Mix well. Alternately blend in confectioners sugar with milk. Beat until smooth. (I usually add more confectioners sugar for a suitable consistency).
Frost with chocolate frosting.




